Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Daniel Henderson's avatar

This was great. Those last lines are really gonna stick with me. Thanks for this.

Expand full comment
Jonah Ogilwy's avatar

Hi Jimmy, this is re our coversation in notes about the value of criticism, so here goes:

You're a very skillful writer, obviously a pro. In this story, you have a concept (the boy doesn't know who his father is, the father wants to tell him) that engages the reader. As you explain this concept, you reveal the character of Bobby Erdkomer and the nature of the world that he inhabits and depict his dilemma. You do all that well, but you might fail to engage the reader due to the depressing nature of your fictional universe. In the universe of your story, characters have nothing more to aspire to than becoming pinball champion and having illegitimate children. So it isn't clear why it matters whether the boy knows who his father is or not. How will anything change in this dead-end town, how will anyone's life be better if the boy knows the truth? Maybe depicting Erdkommer’s loneliness and longing for connection might give the reader some hope and inject energy into the story.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts